Skip to main content

How to Interpret the Load Characteristics Graphs

INSCYD’s “Load Characteristics” visualization is the heart and soul of the metabolic profile. It displays the “behavior” of several physiological metrics as a function of power (in cycling, rowing etc.) or speed

(in running, swimming, etc.). Understanding the load characteristics chart, and using it for training recommendations will allow you to get the most out of INSCYD. Additionally, explaining the chart to your athletes and clients will also have important benefits you don't want to miss:

• a) Show your athletes a complete understanding of how performance, nutrition, training, and race results intersect; in easy to present and understand graphs.

• b) Your athletes will understand the test results and will value the testing service your provide, ensuring higher levels of retention and work of mouth sales of testing/coaching services.

In our experience, with thousands of athletes, 8 out of 10 athletes who received a proper explanation of the load characteristics chart are so impressed with the metrics they don’t turn to any other type of

testing and performance benchmarking.

Let’s get started and understand each of the metrics, and how to leverage them in our coaching and describing them to our athletes.

1. Metabolic Demand & VO₂

It all begins with the metabolic demand curve (navy blue). This curve displays the metabolic demand at steady state as a function of power/speed (mathematically speaking, time is infinite here). Note: We

could have also used energy demand instead, which would have then be displayed in kJ or kcal. Remember, 1 liter of VO2 delivers approximately 21 kJ of metabolic energy per minute. Therefore, the two can be used interchangeably. Why is INSCYD using oxygen uptake in ml/min/kg instead of kJ or kcal to display energy demand? Simply: it makes it easier to compare to the actual oxygen uptake.

The light blue curve shows the actual oxygen uptake rate; in steady state conditions. As you can see, at low intensities (power/speed) there is no significant difference between the actual oxygen demand and the actual oxygen uptake. This means that more or less all the needed oxygen (or energy) is covered by aerobic metabolism. At higher intensities, though, there is a gap opening up – marked by the blue area. This gap can be called the glycolytic or anaerobic gap. It is the difference between the

oxygen needed and the actual oxygen uptake (of your athlete).

In practice, you will notice athletes with a high glycolytic capacity (high VLamax) show a greater gap compared to athletes with a lower glycolytic capacity (lower VLamax). This proves that a highly developed glycolytic metabolism (developed through training and/or only by predisposition) gets more dominant as a source of energy supply. In contrast: in an athlete with a high VO2max (highly developed aerobic metabolism) and low VLamax, you will be able to see only a small glycolytic gap, proving the dominance of the aerobic metabolism over the anaerobic.

Takeaway massage: the “Metabolic demand & VO2” graph allows you to understand

• the relation between speed or power and energy demand – which is what people call economy. The less oxygen your athlete needs for a certain power/speed, the better.

• How much of the energy or oxygen demand is covered by aerobic metabolism (VO2) – at any given speed/power.

• How much of the needed energy is covered by anaerobic (glycolytic) energy metabolism.

2. Lactate production & oxidation

Let’s start with the lactate combustion rate – the (navy) blue curve. What do athletes do in order to recover from hard interval efforts? Every athlete uses a recovery period in between hard intervals to keep moving and keep his/her metabolism running. Imagine lying down, instead and not move at all. How would your muscles feel when you get up to do the next interval?

This example shows not only coaches, but also athletes, know it is better to keep moving in order to recover faster from a hard effort. The reason for this is? Lactate gets combusted faster when we move. Or, in a more scientific way: the only (significant) way to get rid of lactate is to use it as a fuel in the aerobic metabolism. This is why you should picture lactate as a “fuel for the muscles”. Plus, the reconversion of lactate back to glucose – during exercise – isn’t quantitatively significant.

Once we acknowledge the main pathway to use lactate is as a fuel in the aerobic metabolism, it should become clear: the rate of lactate combustion in the aerobic metabolism is determined by the rate of

the aerobic metabolism itself. In other words; the higher the aerobic rate in a given metabolism, the more lactate can be used as a fuel. This is what the blue curve shows, i.e. the maximum aerobic combustion rate of an athlete. This rate originates from the oxygen uptake rate displayed in the graph above, and it is expressed as a flux rate: mmol of lactate per minute. You may also look at it as the gross lactate combustion rate in the aerobic metabolism.

The red curve, on the other hand, shows the actual lactate production rate. The lactate production rate depends on the anaerobic – or, more precisely, on the glycolytic power of the athlete (VLamax). The

higher this rate is, the more lactate he or she will produce at any given intensity. One of the most interesting states of energy metabolism is the crossing point of lactate production and lactate combustion (red and blue curve). At this intensity, both pathways (the aerobic lactate combustion and the glycolytic lactate production) run at the exact same rate. The lactate production equals the lactate combustion rate. This point marks the highest possible intensity at which blood lactate level would

stabilize (steady state).

Zoom into the graph to see it in more detail- at an intensity below the crossing point (left hand side) the maximum possible combustion is always higher then the actual production. At an intensity above

the crossing point (right hand side of the graph), the production rate exceeds the combustion rate. Lactate accumulates until an athlete reduces intensity, and there is no possible steady state of blood

lactate level. That is why the crossing point marks the maximum lactate steady state, or as people call it: the anaerobic threshold.

The crossing point has been validated numerous times by comparing the power/speed at the crossing point against the gold standard: 30-minute tests at a steady power while monitoring the blood lactate level to see if a steady state can be reached. These verification studies have been performed in several sports, with male and females (something usually not done with simple lactate profile tests). The average tolerance of the power/speed at the crossing point compared to the gold standard is

always in the range of 2 – 2.5%. This is significant lower then any other physiological test aiming to determine the anaerobic threshold (and this has caught the interest of professional teams who need to identify and track even the smallest changes in the performance of their athletes).

3. Lactate Clearance Rate & Lactate Accumulation Rate

This graph may well be one of the most compelling and important parts of INSCYD. To understand it better, let’s start with the gross lactate production (red) and combustion rate (blue) discussed in the

previous graph (section 2: Lactate production & oxidation) . Below threshold, so below the crossing point of the blue and red curve, there is a gap between how much lactate could be combusted in the

aerobic metabolism and how much lactate actually gets produced. As lactate gets transformed to pyruvate before it enters the aerobic metabolism (at least the by far biggest amount of it), the difference between the lactate produced and the fuel needed can be named “the Lactate Clearance Rate”. This is what the grey curve shows you here.

Now, imagine the athlete accumulated a large amount of lactate during an effort and he/she wants to get rid of it and exercises at lower intensity. The upper ceiling of how much lactate can get consumed is still defined by the maximum aerobic lactate combustion (blue curve, graph 2). But there is also a gross production – the red curve in graph number 2. The gap between gross production and lactate combustion is the possibility to use additional lactate as a fuel (the additional lactate that was accumulated in a hard effort). This is what the grey curve named “Lactate Clearance Rate” shows you. In practical applications, the grey curve shows you the ability of the athlete to recover as a function of speed or power.

Please note the curve is in mmol/l/min. For example: imagine the apex of the curve being at 1 mmol/l/min and the athlete accumulated an extra 8 mmol/l in the blood during an interval. To fully recover from this effort, and to get rid of the lactate it would take him/her 8 / 1 = 8 min. Now, imagine the athlete isn’t able to recover at the apex of the curve, but it is forced to ride at a much higher intensity (because he/she is competing, and the race dictates the intensity). Imagine the athlete has to hold an intensity to the right of the apex, and the Lactate Clearance Rate isn’t 1 mmol/l/min but only 0.5; the recovery time would be 8 / 0.5 = 16 min.

You can also see that the Lactate Clearance Rate becomes 0 at one intensity – this is the intensity where the metabolism is saturated with lactate/pyruvate. Again, this is what people call the anaerobic

threshold.

At higher intensities lactate accumulates more and more – which can be seen in the purple Lactate Accumulation Rate curve. This one shows you the rate at which lactate accumulates (mmol/l per minute). Even though lactate is not directly responsible for muscle fatigue or loss of force, it is a valid marker for these feelings. Therefore, the rate of lactate accumulation x the time of accumulation is highly associated with time to fatigue. Therefore, the lower the accumulation rate (= the purple curve

is less steep) the better the athlete will perform riding above threshold.

Please be aware, only smallest differences in the grey and purple curves of Lactate Clearance Rate and Lactate Accumulation Rate can be extremely relevant to the performance in various sports. For example, a cyclist benefits from slower fatigue riding above threshold – and this is where the race is won.

For example. An athlete can reach a maximum of 10 mmol/l lactate above baseline. Let’s imagine his threshold (crossing point) is at 375 watts. At an intensity of 400 watts his accumulation is 1 mmol/l/min. This means he would be able to ride 10 / 1 = 10 min at 400 watts to reach his limit of 10 mmol/l of lactate. Now imagine his accumulation at 400 watts is not 1 mmol/l/min but only 0.9 mmol/l/lmin. This sounds like a very small difference. But let’s do the math here. To reach his ceiling of 10 mmol/l/min he can now ride 10 / 0.9 = 11 minutes 6 seconds at 400 watts. This is more than one minute longer, which can be absolutely decisive for a race.

Please see our whitepaper on lactate accumulation and recovery for further details

4. Fat and Carbohydrate combustion

The fat and carbohydrate combustion graph is very important for fueling, low intensity training and providing pacing and fueling strategies for athletes:

The fat combustion curve is shown in kcal/h as a function of speed/power. The apex of the curve +/-5% is marked with the green area. Use the mouse over the function to read the actual combustion rates below the graph. You may well find in the area of the apex of the curve, there isn’t a great difference in fat combustion rates. Often a decrease of intensity (power/speed) by 10% doesn't make any difference in practical application in training.

The red curve shows the actual carbohydrate combustion rate. As it can be seen, this curve doesn't display an apex: the higher the intensity, the higher the combustion rate is. In additional to the kcal/h unit, the carbohydrate combustion is also shown in g/h on the right y-axis. The known and maximum exogenous uptake rate of 60-90 g of carbohydrates per hour is marked with an orange bar.

You may use the fat and carbohydrate combustion curve to specify zones for low intensity endurance training. You may also use those curves to prescribe fueling recommendations for training and racing.

Please see our guideline on how to create individual fueling strategies for details on how to apply this to practice.

5. Aerobic and Anaerobic Energy Contribution (%)

This graph shows the percentage of energy supplied by the aerobic and anaerobic systems as a function of exercise intensity. The X-axis is speed or power, as in the other Load Characteristics graphs. The Y-axis shows the share of total energy supply: aerobic is blue and anaerobic is red.

All Load Characteristics graphs represent steady-state conditions. Accordingly, the anaerobic share in this graph refers to glycolytic energy supply; phosphocreatine is not shown because its contribution is

relevant to non-steady-state efforts.

Aerobic energy production refers to energy supplied through oxygen-dependent metabolism, including the citric acid cycle and oxidative phosphorylation. It does not indicate how much of that energy originates from fat or carbohydrate. For substrate use, refer to the Fat and Carbohydrate Combustion graphs.

6. Fat and Carbohydrate Contribution (%)

This chart expresses fat and carbohydrate use as percentages of substrate-based energy supply across exercise intensities. The X-axis shows speed or power. The green curve/area represents fat; the

orange curve/area represents carbohydrate.

Unlike the absolute Fat and Carbohydrate Combustion chart, which reports values such as kcal/h and carbohydrate g/h, this chart shows their relative shares at each intensity. It is useful for explaining how

the fuel mixture changes with increasing workload.

Did this answer your question?